they are visible for me one one browser, but not on another. May be that default node is having some trouble.

Firefox/Debian no joy so far

‘#14’ now visible

It eventually loaded for me, but from a fresh browser instance it took quite a while for anything at all to show up

here we go… :lifter:

oooh, few votes trickling in too - cool!

(possibly dumb question, apologies in advance)… How do we know which votes are which? They have different ‘#-n’ numbers now 🤔

does it not look like that @julian ?

Not yet

Have reloaded page, waiting. Will upload screenshot

please do! older orgs do generally take longer to load if you haven’t looked at them and cached them recently. it’s something we’re working on improving :)

How come not Bella?

what about Bella?

Oh sorry, is it my org that needs to update to Bella (see screenshot) 😊

same btw atm (no text)

ah right

logistical challenge

I think a supermajority of all ANT holders would have to approve it due to how the org is configured

@light ouch

Yay! And we’re good to go. All text present and correct. :partyparrot:

look at it again, it might just be 2/3 of voters on a given upgrade, like a meta track proposal

looking at it again, it might just be 2/3 of voters on a given upgrade, like a meta track proposal

@light Sounds doable

yeah

we should do it during a not-AGP vote

so as not to confuse the voters this time

Current numbers would suggest higher voter turnout this time (obv. early doors but…)

Hey guys. As per AGP-1, dropping into the gov channel to share a proposal to separate Signalling from Voting.

AGPs are a wonderful tool to give the community a voice and guide Aragon’s decision making. Before submitting proposals for concrete decision making, there is often a need to gather signals from the community. This can happen in the forum, but in a heated and long term debates it’s often impractical to measure sentiment without getting overwhelmed. The Aragon community realizes this and has created an awesome signalling app.

I propose that the signalling app be updated so that it is fully functional and can included in the AGP-1 doc as part of Stage 2: preproposal. This would require all AGPs to use the signalling app to gather sentiment from the community along with current methods of forum posts and AMAs before drafting a proposal. This metric can then be taken into consideration by the AGP Editors during Stage 3: Draft.

Please share thoughts on this and/or what needs to happen from a technical perspective to make it possible. Once a more concrete plan is in place, a submission as a Meta AGP seems appropriate. Thanks :)

There’s also a thread on the forum and issue opened on the GitHub repo

• https://forum.aragon.org/t/meta-separation-of-signalling-and-voting-51/871
• https://github.com/aragon/AGPs/issues/51

re quadratic voting - 👀 https://twitter.com/DeanEigenmann/status/1121761276991082496