88 Members
Egoist Communism. Nihilist Communism. Anarchy not Anarchism? Post-Left. Green Anarchy. Post-Primitivism31 Servers

Load older messages

28 Aug 2020
@ana:rchist.netZulikathSorry for slow replies, at dinner01:00:30

I’m saying you can read it knowing how Hegel and others framed things and integrate those framings into your interpretation without assuming those framings are being used to agree with the positions of the earlier thinkers. I don’t know how you could possibly live without ever reading something and thinking “Wow, that’s such bullshit, I know that’s wrong” and reacting against it. In many places the book can be read as a negation and reaction against earlier ideas.

If we’re saying that Stirner probably thought that being a hypocrite was bad, sure, I agree. But he’s not making a value judgement on it there. Being a hypocrite is bad in terms of reasoning, it means that you can’t rely on your reasoning if your reasoning contradicts your actions, positively, not normatively. And that’s the only relevant aspect of it here, as far as I can see.

So I mean I agree that being a hypocrite is bad, and Stirner probably thought that too, but it’s still conditional to what your goals are, and you can presume here that Stirner values correctness of reasoning. But Stirner doesn’t give you any norms or values or morals to act on, including not being a hypocrite, he just assumes you already hold that value and if you don’t then it doesn’t appeal to you.

@ana:rchist.netZulikath changed their display name from Zhwazi to Zulikath.03:58:40
@ana:rchist.netZulikath changed their profile picture.03:58:44
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgi think we agree as i never said morals i just said 'should' not all ort statements are moral ones they can be merely ethical or prescriptive14:41:35
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.organd the diffrence between what is ethical and what is logically the best course of action is very grey14:42:21
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgi do read things and think there bs, i think both stirner and hegel are bs14:42:56
29 Aug 2020
@androv:matrix.organdrov joined the room.16:34:21
30 Aug 2020
@ikx:matrix.orgikx joined the room.19:15:54
1 Sep 2020
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgAnyone intrested in accelerationism?20:24:10
@ana:rchist.netZulikathInterested like curious, but not interested like actively pursuing thought in20:25:10
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgAh fair20:28:04
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgIm l/acc20:28:16
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.orgI was just hoping to find decent acc protests20:28:38
7 Sep 2020
@ikx:matrix.orgikx changed their profile picture.05:40:04
@ikx:matrix.orgikx changed their profile picture.05:41:01
9 Sep 2020
@diamondtoken:matrix.org@diamondtoken:matrix.org joined the room.00:18:00
13 Sep 2020
@byetc:matrix.orgbyetc joined the room.23:02:35
14 Sep 2020
@nuke1979:matrix.org@nuke1979:matrix.org left the room.03:45:54
@gh0st:matrix.org@gh0st:matrix.org joined the room.16:52:30
16 Sep 2020
@janjan:synod.im@janjan:synod.im left the room.23:09:30
17 Sep 2020
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.org set a profile picture.00:30:38
26 Sep 2020
@peter:perthchat.orgpeter joined the room.14:40:07
18 Sep 2020
@smoh:matrix.orgsmoh joined the room.08:16:11
19 Sep 2020
@gh0st:matrix.org@gh0st:matrix.org left the room.11:39:47
@diamondtoken:matrix.org@diamondtoken:matrix.org left the room.12:37:32
@tywyllwch:matrix.org@tywyllwch:matrix.org left the room.15:55:52
@nick_forleuze:matrix.orgビンセント・ロウ joined the room.17:19:39
20 Sep 2020
@nick_forleuze:matrix.orgビンセント・ロウ changed their display name from My o key was fucking br0ken but now i remapped it to ビンセント・ロウ.19:28:08

There are no newer messages yet.

Back to Room List