!NasysSDfxKxZBzJJoE:matrix.org

#matrix-spec

354 Members
Discussion of specific Matrix Spec Change (MSC) proposals and surrounding ideas | https://spec.matrix.org/unstable/proposals/ | SCT Board: https://github.com/orgs/matrix-org/projects/31 | Old design drafts: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B4wHq8qP86r2ck15MHEwMmlNVUk 143 Servers

Load older messages


SenderMessageTime
18 May 2022
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAminda
In reply to @clokep:matrix.org
(But because it isn't specced, Element cannot depend on it so you could get weird situations.)
So the bottom line is that it should be Specced for Element to rely on it?
13:29:37
@clokep:matrix.orgclokep
In reply to @Ciblia:matrix.org
So the bottom line is that it should be Specced for Element to rely on it?
Yes. Honestly it is probably like a 100 word MSC. ☹️
13:31:10
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAminda
In reply to @clokep:matrix.org
Yes. Honestly it is probably like a 100 word MSC. ☹️
oh, thanks, that sounds great
13:32:43
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindathis shall be my first attempt at a SMC13:38:41
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAminda * this shall be my first attempt at a MSC13:38:49
@andybalaam:matrix.organdybalaamDrop a draft here and people should be happy to help out13:39:41
@clokep:matrix.orgclokepYep, would be happy to proof it for you, just don't have time to do it myself. ☹️ 13:41:38
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindahttps://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/3818 is the initial version, can I just erase the non-applicable sections?13:54:48
@clokep:matrix.orgclokepUsually it is best to leave most of them to show you've thought about it. 🙂 13:56:56
@cat:feline.supportCatRendered is missing 14:05:21
@cat:feline.supportCatSo that is a part of the criticism i can issue to the MSC. 14:05:39
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaoh, I didn't see a PR template, I guess I will add it14:06:33
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaI also opened https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec/issues/1072 on the other problem14:06:50
@andybalaam:matrix.organdybalaam
In reply to @Ciblia:matrix.org
https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/3818 is the initial version, can I just erase the non-applicable sections?
This looks good. Can you give a link to the exact part of the spec that needs changing, and suggest the exact wording that should go there?
14:23:16
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaI can try, I guess14:24:09
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAminda
In reply to @andybalaam:matrix.org
This looks good. Can you give a link to the exact part of the spec that needs changing, and suggest the exact wording that should go there?
I think the part in the spec that needs changing is somewhere in https://spec.matrix.org/v1.2/client-server-api/#room-upgrades, but I don't see where exactly or what should be added there
14:28:06
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaand I only find that because it was mentioned in https://github.com/vector-im/element-web/issues/19208#issuecomment-113000827514:28:42
@andybalaam:matrix.organdybalaam
In reply to @Ciblia:matrix.org
and I only find that because it was mentioned in https://github.com/vector-im/element-web/issues/19208#issuecomment-1130008275
I think it would be somewhere in Server behaviour https://spec.matrix.org/v1.2/client-server-api/#server-behaviour-16
14:29:02
@clokep:matrix.orgclokepProviding exact wording of what needs to be changed shouldn't be necessary, but linking to the part of the spec is appreciated! 🙂 14:35:04
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaoh, I already did that14:37:17
@andybalaam:matrix.organdybalaamI left a small comment and a ✔️14:43:48
@mscbot:amorgan.xyzmscbot[MSC3818] "MSC3818: Copy room type on upgrade" has been created: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/381814:53:20
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAmindaOh, is it a problem that this seems to be a subset of https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/3385 or can that always be updated afterwards?14:55:57
@clokep:matrix.orgclokepNot a problem. 🙂 14:56:19
@Ciblia:matrix.orgAminda clokep: regarding your change suggestion, is /latest/ ok or shouldn't it be /1.2/ ? 15:16:21
@clokep:matrix.orgclokepErrr, probably 1.2 is a better idea.15:16:54
@___nick___:libera.chat___nick___ left the room.17:14:31
@___nick___:libera.chat___nick___ joined the room.17:16:22
@___nick___:libera.chat___nick___ left the room.17:41:14
@___nick___:libera.chat___nick___ joined the room.17:46:41

There are no newer messages yet.


Back to Room List